The Jewish statehood began with debate.

Rediscover Zionism this fall – its significance, its wisdom and its place in contemporary Israel and Jewish life. This is your opportunity to renew the great debate that led to the establishment of the State of Israel, and the strengthening of Jewish pride and identity throughout the world.

This fall, throughout Tishrei and especially during Sukkot, the Menachem Begin Heritage Center, with the generous support of the Schusterman Foundation, is encouraging a grassroots, Zionist conversation through Israel, and the Jewish world. Inspired by the publication this spring of a definitive
Zionist anthology, Professor Gil Troy’s The Zionist Ideas – we want to reignite a conversation about the most transformative and consequential set of ideas in modern Jewish history.
In 1948, Israel was fragile, the Zionist conversation was robust. Today, Israel is robust – the Zionist conversation has turned fragile. The Zionist Salons are an opportunity to jump-start conversations about Jewish peoplehood, Jewish statehood, and finding personal meaning through those frameworks.
Starting with the holiday of Sukkot – and building over the next few months, dozens of people all over Israel – and throughout the Jewish world — have already volunteered to host "Zionist Salons" — conversations in their Sukkot, around their dining room tables, in their backyards, in community centers, about what "Israel means to me" today. This is a chance to move beyond partisanship, go beyond the headlines, and go back to the basics. 
We encourage people to be creative, to be civil, to be constructive — the idea here is to go back to the beginning, remembering that democracy begins in conversation, Jewish statehood began with debate – and we need to return to that discourse and to those core ideas that helped shape our state.

Below are ten different guidebooks, for ten different discussion topics, all based around texts from The Zionist Ideas, by Gil Troy, available in English (only, for now) on Amazon and from the Jewish Publication Society.
Each book begins with the same two pages of introduction, explaining the concept of the Zionist Salons.  What follows is guidance for the specific salon itself, explaining the topic, introducing the texts, and posing questions for discussion.
Each guidebook concludes with a description, for reference, of the ‘six traditional schools of Zionism’ into which the various Zionist texts are divided. 
Good luck. If you have any questions, please email – if you have any photos – post them on social networks with the hashtag #zionistsalon.
If you have any conclusions, any Zionist visions you wish to share, email them to us — anonymously or in your name.

Easy as 1,2,3: In a few minutes you'll have the booklets in your email!

Select a booklet and enter your email. Wait less than a few minutes.

Print the booklet for the number of guests you expect to host

Invite your guests and let the debate begin!

Salon #1

ZIONISM 101: An introductory look at what Zionism is and where I fit in – if it all.

“The Zionist idea, recognizing the Jews as a people – Am Yisrael — with rights to establish a state – Medinat Yisrael — in their homeland, Eretz Yisra’el.” Professor Gil Troy, Zionist activist and author


Salon #2

Basic Zionist One-Liners – Simple Slogans, Profound Ideas

Here’s the challenge: can each of you take a random quotation from a Zionist thinker as a key to conversation, whether we agree with the idea – or not.

“Our parents’ heroism enabled us to establish a living, happy society in Israel.” Rachel Sharansky Danziger, Israeli writer, daughter of Natan and Avital Sharansky

Salon #3

The Zionist conversation is rich and vibrant. Categorizing Zionists into six major schools of thought help us understand it better – and find our personal gateway in.

“Mutual responsibility became even more powerful once a distinct association was established for the sake of a single purpose, a single ship: the State of Israel.” Rabbi Yaakov Medan, dean of Yeshivat Har Etzion (Gush), a flagship Religious-Zionist institution in Alon Shevut.


Salon #4

By now, most Israelis were “born Zionist” – rather than having chosen to come to Israel on Aliyah – what then is the nature of Israeli Zionism – and how does it compare to Aliyah-based Zionism?

“I am a Zionist. The first time I saw my son wearing an IDF uniform I burst into tears, I haven’t missed the Independence Day torch-lighting ceremony for twenty years now, and my television was made in Korea, but I taught it to cheer for our national soccer team.” Yair Lapid, Israeli media personality and politician

Salon #5

To what extent is Zionism a reaction to oppression – and to what extent does it express our identity as a people and our connection to our homeland? 

“The duty and aim of Betar is very simple though difficult: to create that type of Jew which the nation needs in order to better and quicker build a Jewish state. In other words, to create a ‘normal,’ ‘healthy’ citizen for the Jewish nation.” Ze’ev Jabotinsky, Revisionist Zionist thinker


Salon #6

This salon focuses on one school of Zionist thought, Religious Zionism, exploring its agenda – balancing its concern with the land with how we live on the land.

“The real and organic holiness of Jewry can become manifest only by the return of the people to its land, the only path that can lead to its renascence.” Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook, Chief Rabbi of Palestine and Religious Zionist thinker

Salon #7

This salon addresses one of the hot issues of 2018 – how Israel balances Zionism’s dual commitment to creating a Jewish and democratic state. 

“As feminists and members of national and racial minorities discovered long ago, the idea that a state can be void of any cultural, historical, or linguistic affiliation is a misleading illusion—which is not only naive but also oppressive.” Yuli Tamir, academic and former Labor Party Minister


Salon #8

This salon explores Zionism’s deep progressive roots – and ongoing progressive vision – even though Zionism might not be “politically correct” today.

“Am Segula implies an extra burden, an added responsibility to perform with a virtue born of conscience and to listen to what Elijah later called ‘the still, small voice’.” David Ben-Gurion, first Israeli Prime Minister

Salon #9

This salon raises issues about assimilation, examining Israel through an identity lens not just a political one as a way of shaping an effective response to some of our most personal, existential dilemmas.

“The rediscovery of my identity, my community, my people, gave me the strength to fight for my rights, for the rights of other Jews, and for the rights of others, allying me with dissidents fighting communist tyranny.” Natan Sharansky, former Soviet Jewish refusenik and political prisoner, later Chair of the Jewish Agency


Salon #10

The essential underlying question here, as Zionists, is what is the nature of the relationship between the State of Israel and all of the Jewish people, wherever they may live? 

“Judaism… seeks to return to its historic center where it will be able to live a life developing in a natural way, to bring its powers into play in every department of human culture, to broaden and perfect those national possessions which it has acquired up to now, and thus to contribute to the common stock of humanity.” Ahad Ha’am, Cultural Zionist thinker